1/2 lb = 30 pieces
1 lb = 60 Pieces
5 lb = 300 Pieces
20 lb = 1200 Pieces
You know what they say: sweets for the sweet. Give someone sweet in your life this assorted and delicious mix of gourmet salt water taffy.
Our "Favorites" assortment includes the following mouth-watering flavors: Grape, Cinnamon Swirl, Raspberry, Strawberry, Pineapple, Blueberry, Lemon Meringue, Orange Cream, Chocolate Chip, Green Apple, Rootbeer Float, Raspberry Lemonade, Watermelon, Caramel Swirl, Banana, Vanilla, Peppermint, S'mores, Frosted Cupcake, and Cherry.
Taffy Shop's Assorted Mix salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.
Showing reviews 1-10 of 41 | Next
Posted by Joanne Polk on 8th Oct 2014
We purchased a large quantity of " pick your own " assortment of taffy to use as part of wedding favor bags. I had to hide it before we filled the bags because everyone kept eating them. I admit I had a few myself. The flavors we chose were maple bacon, candy apple, huckleberry, pumpkin pie and candy corn. All super delicious. The texture of these candies made them melt in your mouth. I will definitely order from the Taffy Shop again. Their staff was super attentive and helped me through the process.. Best taffy I probably ever had.
Posted by John B on 5th Oct 2014
the taffy was soft,great tasting.they shipped my order right away.I will get my taffy from the Taffy Shop
Posted by Sharon on 18th Sep 2014
Was having "taffy withdrawal" following our beach vacation and found your website just in time. Really like being able to pick exactly what I wanted. Taffy arrived quickly and is extremely fresh and more flavor than what we bought at the beach. Thank you! Thank you! Thank you!
Posted by Unknown on 16th Sep 2014
This taffy is very tasty and fresh. It arrived quickly and in excellent condition.
Posted by Jordan Meme on 5th Aug 2014
Every flavour is unique and my teeth are full of holes! MUST ORDER AGAIN
Posted by Tammy Lenske on 12th Jun 2014
We bought this taffy for our daughters wedding at the end of the month to give as a wedding favor. We bought two 5 lb. bags for the wedding and one 2 lb. bag for us to try. We went through the 2 lb. bag in no time. My husband has already opened the 5 lb. bag. He said you just need to order more for the wedding. This is absolutely the best taffy we have ever had! The texture is so smooth, and the flavors are awesome!
Posted by Hilary Stagliano on 27th May 2014
I was a little afraid to order taffy via the internet - worried that it wouldn't be fresh. Not the case!! The Taffy Shop "Favorites" assortment was fresh, delicious and I received it quicker than expected! Would definitely recommend to anyone, and have already ordered more to stuff in party favors for an "Under the Sea" themed baby shower!!
Posted by Vicki on 13th May 2014
I order this Taffy by the 5# bag for work and they LOVE IT.....
Posted by Unknown on 27th Apr 2014
I ordered several varieties and enjoyed them all. Soft, chewy and full flavors in every piece. Will be buying more as soon as possible.
Posted by Morgan on 12th Apr 2014
Hi I tried your taffy for the first time at a little sandwich shop in town. It was so good I decided to place a order online. The order arrived very quickly and was beautifully packaged. The only problem I have is that my brother in law won't keep his hands off it!!! I just ordered 2 more pounds! I would really like to hide it but it's so good I keep telling everybody about it.
Showing reviews 1-10 of 41 | Next