Creamy Caramel

(12 reviews) Write a Review
  • Creamy Caramel Salt Water Taffy
  • Creamy Caramel
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Guide
  • Creamy Caramel Salt Water Taffy
  • Creamy Caramel
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Guide


For an incredibly pleasurable and palatable experience, we highly recommend that you let our gourmet Creamy Caramel taffy stay on your tongue for as long as possible. Taffy Shop's Creamy Caramel salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Approximate Pieces Per Bag:

  • 1/2 lb - 27 pieces
  • 1 lb - 54 pieces
  • 2 lbs - 108 pieces
  • 5 lbs - 270 pieces
View AllClose

12 Reviews

  • 5

    Posted by carol on 24th Jun 2021

    love this caramel

  • 5
    The Best Ever

    Posted by Kathy Hirsch on 30th Nov 2017

    Brought my sister from Indiana to your shop and we fell in love with the taffy. We’ll get fat ordering and eating but is superior for sure. Send her some every other month!

  • 5
    Favorite item on the Candy Buffet table!

    Posted by cinnamon kunelis on 26th Jun 2016

    Decided to order these last minute to fill in my candy buffet table for my nieces graduation party. It got around quickly that all the taffy was amazing! The older crowd absolutely went crazy for these. It's nice to have hit a home run with that crowd because or family parties are big and range from newborn to 95yrs old. The kids favorites are the sour stuff but now I have great opinions for the older crowd.
    Will definitely order again!

  • 5
    Nice vanilla and caramel combo

    Posted by Unknown on 18th Apr 2016

    I loved the combination of the two flavors.

  • 5
    caramel taffy

    Posted by Ruth Anderson on 8th Dec 2015


  • 3
    Too tough and sticks to teeth

    Posted by Stanislav Zak on 8th Feb 2015

    I love caramel and I love Salt Water Taffy, so for me it was a no brainer that I ordered this flavor. However, I was a tad disappointed: unlike other flavors that were soft and melted in the mouth, this one was tough and stuck to my teeth too much to my liking. Other flavors don't stick to teeth. Alas, I guess I'll stick with vanilla - my perennial favorite!

  • 5
    The best caramel taffy!

    Posted by Unknown on 10th Dec 2014

    I discovered this taffy while on vacation at Lake is the best. Very smooth. This is my favorite flavor!

  • 5

    Posted by kate on 4th Aug 2014

    I've fallen in love with this candy.

  • 5
    This is my favorite one

    Posted by Ernest on 18th Dec 2013

    A nice combination of flavor and texture!

  • 5
    Excellent Taffy

    Posted by Teresa Sipple on 12th Aug 2013

    This caramel swirl taffy was the best I hae ever had. Will be ordering more soon.

  • 5
    One of the best!

    Posted by Unknown on 17th Jul 2013

    This is one of my favorites.....very rich and chewy.

  • 4
    Good but could be better

    Posted by Unknown on 9th Jul 2013

    I love all your taffy flavors but I think this could be a tad more caramelly.

View AllClose