Can't decide which taffy to buy? We don't blame you! That's why we offer the Taffy Shop "Create Your Own Assortment" option. Don't settle for just one flavor, you've got a half pound of variety and can choose up to 3 different flavors. Taffy Shop's salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.
Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 30
Flavors were good
We chose maple bacon, watermelon, and frozen root beer float. Maple bacon had a goofy after taste so we weren't a huge fan of that one. But he really did love the watermelon one. Will be trying more flavors.
Greatest taffy in the world!
The taffy was very delicious and I likes creating a bag with all the kinds of taffy I wanted. My shipping was 6-ish dollars and arrived in one week.
This is the best taffy I’ve ever had. I got it for my parents and my mom absolutely loved it! My dad has esophageal cancer and the taffy was so soft he was able to swallow it with little to no problem. I recommend this taffy to anyone who wants it.
Perfect, as always. However, I was disappointed that I couldn't order vanilla for my red, white, and blue mix.
The taffy that I received is delish. The flavoring is spot on and the freshness of the taffy is amazing. I definitely will be ordering again soon
I have been a Taffy Shop customer for a few years. I would love to eat more of it. My weight says "hold on here" :) Just received my last bag that included the new Apricot flavor. I ate all of them in one day. Now you see why I need to watch my weight.
I've had my share of taffy over my 50+ years but this taffy is FAR AND AWAY the absolute BEST I've ever tasted. It's soft and creamy, chewy and full of flavor. It makes my mouth water just thinking of it and I can't anticipate when it will arrive because I want it far sooner than the 3 days it takes to get to me!
Everyone is wonderfully nice and professional and the whole operation is as smooth as the candy itself.
There is NO OTHER place I will ever buy Taffy from other than here.
Thanks, gang! You guys all rock!!
Purchase both a pound and half pound assortment. Flavors I purchased in the half pound were root beer, orange creme, strawberry cheesecake. All are delicious. Especially love the root beer.
I love this taffy. I mixed strawberry, vanilla, and choc malt... why no straight chocolate? I prefer the soft pieces. The flavors with the caramel, while flavorful, are not as soft. The choc malt was not as soft and I didn't get the malt flavoring. It's good to try new things...but, I'll probably stick with my favorites, in the future.
I gave salt water taffy as a birthday gift and they raved about how good it was! The Taffy Shop is the go to place for salt water taffy. Super fast delivery--many thanks!!
