Create Your Own 1/2 LB Mix

(35 reviews) Write a Review
  • Create Your Own 1/2 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 1/2 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart
  • Create Your Own 1/2 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 1/2 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart


Can't decide which taffy to buy? We don't blame you! That's why we offer the Taffy Shop "Create Your Own Assortment" option. Don't settle for just one flavor, you've got a half pound of variety and can choose up to 3 different flavors. Taffy Shop's salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 30

View AllClose

35 Reviews

  • 5
    Amazing as always

    Posted by Melissa on 25th Nov 2018

    Greatest taffy in the world!

  • 5

    Posted by Malia on 27th Oct 2018

    The taffy was very delicious and I likes creating a bag with all the kinds of taffy I wanted. My shipping was 6-ish dollars and arrived in one week.

  • 5
    1/2 Pound Bag

    Posted by Angelica McConnell on 2nd Aug 2018

    This is the best taffy I’ve ever had. I got it for my parents and my mom absolutely loved it! My dad has esophageal cancer and the taffy was so soft he was able to swallow it with little to no problem. I recommend this taffy to anyone who wants it.

  • 5
    1/2 pound mix

    Posted by Christina on 30th Jun 2018

    Perfect, as always. However, I was disappointed that I couldn't order vanilla for my red, white, and blue mix.

  • 5
    oh yum

    Posted by Maria on 11th Jun 2018

    The taffy that I received is delish. The flavoring is spot on and the freshness of the taffy is amazing. I definitely will be ordering again soon

  • 5
    Another Delicious Assortment

    Posted by JeffinMass on 25th Jan 2018

    I have been a Taffy Shop customer for a few years. I would love to eat more of it. My weight says "hold on here" :) Just received my last bag that included the new Apricot flavor. I ate all of them in one day. Now you see why I need to watch my weight.

  • 5
    DO NOT "Pass GO" without this Taffy!

    Posted by Debbye on 30th Dec 2016

    I've had my share of taffy over my 50+ years but this taffy is FAR AND AWAY the absolute BEST I've ever tasted. It's soft and creamy, chewy and full of flavor. It makes my mouth water just thinking of it and I can't anticipate when it will arrive because I want it far sooner than the 3 days it takes to get to me!
    Everyone is wonderfully nice and professional and the whole operation is as smooth as the candy itself.
    There is NO OTHER place I will ever buy Taffy from other than here.
    Thanks, gang! You guys all rock!!

  • 5
    Awesome taffy

    Posted by Sharon Quick on 20th Oct 2016

    Purchase both a pound and half pound assortment. Flavors I purchased in the half pound were root beer, orange creme, strawberry cheesecake. All are delicious. Especially love the root beer.

  • 5
    Great fun creating my mix

    Posted by Unknown on 10th Sep 2016

    I love this taffy. I mixed strawberry, vanilla, and choc malt... why no straight chocolate? I prefer the soft pieces. The flavors with the caramel, while flavorful, are not as soft. The choc malt was not as soft and I didn't get the malt flavoring. It's good to try new things...but, I'll probably stick with my favorites, in the future.

  • 5
    Always Fresh and Delicious!

    Posted by on 2nd Jun 2016

    I gave salt water taffy as a birthday gift and they raved about how good it was! The Taffy Shop is the go to place for salt water taffy. Super fast delivery--many thanks!!

  • 3
    the last order tasted better

    Posted by kathi prosser on 16th Jan 2016

    I have ordered 3 times now just trying different flavors so far I have tried 9 flavors some were not so good but eggnog smores chocolate chip cookie dough gingerbread maple were soo good omg caramel corn was amazing!that leaves 3 that were not so chocolate was a let down and I am still on the fence with pumpkin pie.oh yeah caramel chocolate mocha was pretty good so 7 out of 9 were good. All in all I would order from the taffy shop again, pretty yummy.

  • 5
    Very Good

    Posted by Donna on 27th Sep 2015

    This is just what I was looking for in a taffy not too sweet and full of flavor. I ordered the dessert and a create my own assortment fantastic!!!Trying now to decide what my next assortment will be! I let several co-workers try some and they're hooked now I gave them the little flavor charts and all the website info to order their own now hint hint lol Oh one more thing about the Taffy Shop the shipping was reasonable and very fast!!!!

View AllClose