Can't decide which taffy to buy? We don't blame you! That's why we offer the Taffy Shop "Create Your Own Mix" option. Don't settle for just one flavor, you've got one full pound of variety. Taffy Shop's salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.
Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 60
I finally found taffy that I actually like and that has distinct flavors. Passion fruit tastes like passion fruit. A++ for taste and softness.
Fantastic flavors and texture!
One lb bag is enough to satisfy for 3-4 people.
Will order again as it was delicious and sweet!
May get two lbs. this time so don't keep ordering!
Highly recommended for salt water Taffy fans and connoisseurs alike.
Delicious and very fresh taffy
Vanilla is the best flavor hands down, but shipping takes too long.
Was happy to find you on the internet. Taffy is hard to find. Some places that do sell taffy have mixed bags of flavors, mostly ones I do not like. It is wonderful to pick the flavors
I am enjoying it. The taffy is quite delicious!
Great flavors to choose from just wish there was molasses and maple flavors from which to choose. Maybe I just missed them in the list. But all flavors are wonderful
Exactly what I expected. My boyfriend loved it!!
This was the best salt water taffy ever. It came quickly to my address. I liked that I could pick whichever flavors I wanted in my mix. It was perfect for the gender reveal party I threw.
Yummy and so fast getting to me
I really love the taffy. I got maple and banana. I honestly cannot stop eating it. I just got the bag, and I have almost ate the whole thing. They also included a sample bag with different flavors to try. Very speedy shipping. Thank you so much. Highly recommend.
