Create Your Own 1 LB Mix

(129 reviews) Write a Review
  • Create Your Own 1 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 1 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart
  • Create Your Own 1 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 1 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart


Can't decide which taffy to buy? We don't blame you! That's why we offer the Taffy Shop "Create Your Own Mix" option. Don't settle for just one flavor, you've got one full pound of variety. Taffy Shop's salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 60

View AllClose

129 Reviews

  • 4
    Mix your own 1 #

    Posted by Deborah Phillips on 4th Dec 2020

    I liked all of them except the white one with orange in the middle, I couldn't tell what flavor it was. The pinta colada was my favorite and the maple bacon was my second favorite. I still liked the chocolate peanut butter too.

  • 5

    Posted by Susan on 12th Nov 2020

    Super easy..

  • 5
    1 # bag of 4 choices of taffy-great flavors

    Posted by jan kittle on 3rd Nov 2020

    enjoying the taffy

  • 5
    Taffy is perfect! The BEST!

    Posted by Anita Youngs on 31st Oct 2020

    I am SO glad I found your online shop! Your flavors are impeccable! Love this product!

  • 5
    Create your own mix

    Posted by Bruce Willis on 26th Oct 2020

    Very tasty. Fresh. Chewy, But not too chewy. I ordered licorice and, I think, root beer Very happy with order.

  • 5
    Make your own bag

    Posted by K Curt on 17th Oct 2020

    I love the make your own mix. When I have gotten taffy at other stores you can only buy a premixed bag, and I end up with several pieces that wont be eaten.
    I have gotten other stores taffy and the flavor is weak. Taffy Shop candy is full of flavor it's the Best!!

  • 5
    A great option if you like to mix and match

    Posted by Rahul Pandya on 24th Sep 2020

    I particularly like this option because it allows you to mix and match just the flavors you'd like to sample. I opted for root beer, coffee, caliente cayenne and tropical guava. Right? My point exactly. Mix the flavors that YOU like to sample

  • 5
    Its a very good product it met all my flavor teauirments.

    Posted by Beverly Potter on 12th Sep 2020

    I'll be buying it again

  • 5
    Mixed chili lime, blueberry blast, key lime, cinnamon buns

    Posted by Thomas Tresner on 3rd Sep 2020

    These were good and vibrant in flavor and readily made soft in the mouth.

  • 5
    Best Taffy -- Bar None!

    Posted by Susan Young on 31st Aug 2020

    As a taffy lover, The Taffy shop is by far the best taffy in the world! I don't even want to admit how much we have ordered this year! Quite simply, best taffy in the US!

  • 5

    Posted by Barbara J. Loomis on 29th Aug 2020


  • 5
    1 pound choose 4 flavors.

    Posted by Deborah on 17th Aug 2020

    Lots of good flavors to choose from. Of course i bought my favorite flavor too.........maple.

View AllClose