Create Your Own 2 LB Mix

(251 reviews) Write a Review
  • Create Your Own 2 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 2 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart
  • Create Your Own 2 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 2 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart


Can't decide which taffy to buy? We don't blame you! That's why we offer the Taffy Shop "Create Your Own Mix" option. Don't settle for just one flavor, you've got two full pounds of variety. Taffy Shop's salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 120

View AllClose

251 Reviews

  • 1
    Hard as a rock.

    Posted by Jennifer on 15th Feb 2020

    I guess we got the bottom of the barrel. This was a gift for a Taffy connoisseur friend of mine, so I didn't open and sample it before sending. Very disappointed in quality.

  • 5
    sooo yummie

    Posted by Monica on 30th Dec 2019

    every flavour is sooo yummie. I love the opportunity to choose my own favourites

  • 4

    Posted by Neshi Foster on 20th Dec 2019

    I love the packaging and all the taffy taste great I just wish shipping was quicker.

  • 5

    Posted by Adam Pike on 6th Dec 2019

    All of the flavors I ordered were delicious. I placed another order yesterday. Strawberry is my favorite

  • 5
    2 pound mix

    Posted by Patricia Howard on 5th Dec 2019

    Love this taffy!!! Have ordered numerous times in the past.

  • 5

    Posted by Sheila on 17th Nov 2019

    I created a custom mix and it is delicious. I love taffy, but I was concerned about ordering online. Worries were unjustified as the taffy is awesome!

  • 5
    Great Taffy!!

    Posted by Gwendolyn Lee on 1st Nov 2019

    Very good favorite was the candy corn, so smooth and rich; I think I like it better than the candy! I ordered more of it!

  • 5
    Great Stuff!!!!!

    Posted by Liz Pietsch on 26th Oct 2019

    This is the best taffy I have ever had. I've tried other taffy and this is the best by far. So very good!!!!

  • 5
    cindy sherburn

    Posted by cindy sherburn on 7th Oct 2019


  • 5
    Everything about this was great!

    Posted by MARK AUSTIN on 3rd Oct 2019

    This whole process was easy and enjoyable. Choosing flavors was fun and easy, they came so quickly and were enjoyed very much

  • 5

    Posted by Kate on 19th Sep 2019

    Can't wait to order another bag with different flavors. The chocolate malt and the peanut butter and jelly were fantastic!

  • 5
    create your own 2# mix

    Posted by Anna Marie Shrum on 13th Sep 2019

    It was absolutely delicious!!! satisfied my Taffy craving.

View AllClose