Create Your Own 2 LB Mix

(271 reviews) Write a Review
  • Create Your Own 2 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 2 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart
  • Create Your Own 2 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 2 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart
$17.29

Description

Can't decide which taffy to buy? We don't blame you! That's why we offer the Taffy Shop "Create Your Own Mix" option. Don't settle for just one flavor, you've got two full pounds of variety. Taffy Shop's salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 120

View AllClose

271 Reviews

  • 5
    best taffy ever

    Posted by Breanna on 11th Aug 2020

    best taffy i have ever had other than from cape cod!! 10/10 recommend fruit punch!!!!!! will buy again this week

  • 4
    Taffy

    Posted by Rene Ginn on 8th Aug 2020

    Very good selection and very yummy!

  • 5
    BEST TAFFY EVER

    Posted by JEANETTE HELD on 26th Jul 2020

    LOVE THAT I CAN PICK OUT THE FLAVORS I LIKE BEST.I THINK THE MACADAMIA IS NEW AND I LOVE IT. KEEP UP THE BEST PRODUCT, FLAVORS ARE TERRIFIC AND THE PRICE IS FAIR.

  • 5
    BEST TAFFY EVER

    Posted by Daniel on 26th Jul 2020


    i wish i could give this more stars because this is the second time ordering the taffy and its to die for itss sooo goood....

  • 5
    The Best!

    Posted by kainoaraymond@gmail.com on 25th Jul 2020

    The best taffy I’ve found, and maybe ever had? The flavors are on point, they ship extremely fast, and their customer service is excellent. This is a delicious, high-quality product. Definitely recommend.

  • 5
    2 pound custom mix

    Posted by Pam G. on 14th Jul 2020

    Taffy was perfect. Not hard and the flavors are delicious. Fast delivery. Would recommend.

  • 5
    2lb create your own bag

    Posted by Debbie on 9th Jul 2020

    Excellent and received quickly. Easy and user friendly website

  • 5
    Excellent customer service

    Posted by Madison Marano on 9th Jul 2020

    I like to order these mixes for my partner that lives in England, because they don’t get them over there. Last time I ordered, I got what I thought they might like, but they told me they wanted different flavors, so I emailed the company and got a very prompt response letting me change the flavors!! It also shipped very quickly, which was super nice. I’ll definitely be coming back next time my partner wants some more!!!

  • 4
    Tastes good but aftertaste is weird

    Posted by jeff on 25th Jun 2020

    The flavors are really good and you can really taste the different flavors initially. The problem is that the aftertaste leaves my mouth feeling plastic-y if that makes sense. There’s something bitter tasting at the end. Maybe this is just taffy normally tastes like? I wished I got a smaller sized bag.

  • 5
    Amazing flavors got here quick

    Posted by James on 6th Jun 2020

    Me and my family destroyed this 2 pound mix so I just ordered the 5 pounder :)

  • 5
    Absolutely the best salt water taffy ever!

    Posted by Tracey Bier on 28th May 2020

    I love the option to pick my favorite flavors!

  • 2
    Peanut butter and jelly

    Posted by bonniehallg@gmail.com on 22nd May 2020

    I loved everything else, but this flavor tasted like very stale peanut butter. Not good. As for the cinnamon, I think I'll try cinnamon bun next as the plain cinnamon is a little firey.

View AllClose