null

Create Your Own 2 LB Mix

(327 reviews) Write a Review
  • Create Your Own 2 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 2 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart
  • Create Your Own 2 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 2 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart
$17.29

Description

Can't decide which taffy to buy? We don't blame you! That's why we offer the Taffy Shop "Create Your Own Mix" option. Don't settle for just one flavor, you've got two full pounds of variety. Taffy Shop's salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 120

View AllClose

327 Reviews

  • 5
    Taffy

    Posted by AEvans on 6th Jul 2021

    Arrived quickly and was tasty and very FRESH!

  • 5
    SIMPLY THE BEST

    Posted by Joanne on 24th Jun 2021

    It was a treat being able to mix just the flavors that I wanted. However, it was hard choosing - they all sounded delicious.
    They arrived in excellent condition and they are soft and yummy. It’s difficult to find any taffy here and when you do, a quick squeeze of the product, and you find it’s rock-hard. Taffy Shop taffy is just right.
    Simply the best.

  • 4
    High quality product, packaging was questionable

    Posted by Jason Hamp on 17th Jun 2021

    The taffy was high quality, the bag itself it came in was solid. The only real issue I had, and the reason I'm not giving this a 5 star rating, is (according to their support) they've got old bags still in circulations that list ingredients they don't use anymore (namely soy lecithin.) They assured me the product I purchased did not have soy lecithin, and I'm inclined to believe them. Still really upset me when I originally got the order and saw that listed, because I had purchased specifically from them because they don't use soy from what I can see (and from what support has told me).

  • 5
    Good tasting taffy

    Posted by Humeston258@Gmail.com on 27th May 2021

    Great tasting taffy and the company itself is awesome!

  • 5
    2 pound package

    Posted by Gene on 22nd May 2021

    Delicious and very flavorful. Also soft while being solid enough that the wrappers come off easily.
    I do wish, however that you allowed a greater variety in the two pound package. Why not six, eight, or ten choices? That would certainly make me even more anxious to buy again.
    Great taffy!

  • 5
    Taffy

    Posted by Jarrett Richards on 12th May 2021

    I have loved salt water taffy since I was a kid. Any trip my parents go on they look for taffy to bring back for me. Last year before covid they went to a store that ordered their taffy from this TaffyShop. By far the best Taffy I have ever tried. I have ordered and eaten at least 15lbs of the stuff over the last year and tried many flavors. My favs in order Caramel and Strawberry Cheesecake, Cotton Candy, Peaches N Cream, Apricot, Mango, Banana Dream, Watermelon, Pineapple Whip, Coconut, Pear, Peanut Butter Jelly.

  • 5
    Great Taffy

    Posted by Derek J Holak on 8th May 2021

    This was my first time ordering from Taffy Shop. I thought all the flavors ordered were good. The only exception was the dill pickle. My wife thought it tatsted like sunflower seeds. I thought the dill pickle flavor was faint. Overall, I will definitely order from Taffy Shop again and try some new flavors!!!

  • 5
    Taffy

    Posted by Sally on 6th May 2021

    Best place online to get taffy, love every order I get! Fast to ship and stays fresh

  • 5
    Delicious taffy!

    Posted by Erica on 5th Apr 2021

    Love the flavors I chose! I think they had to change a couple flavors but that’s not a big deal to me! Yummy!

  • 5
    Taffy 2 lb custom

    Posted by Stuart Doss on 27th Mar 2021

    Flavors are fantastic

  • 5
    2 pound create your own

    Posted by Nancy Watson on 20th Mar 2021

    Taffy was nice and soft. The flavors I chose were very good. Would order again.

  • 5
    Taffy

    Posted by Marcie Ostermeier on 10th Mar 2021

    Always fresh, friends love it, thank you

View AllClose