Create Your Own 5 LB Mix

(235 reviews) Write a Review
Weight:
5.01 LBS
Shipping:
Calculated at Checkout
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart
$26.99

Description

Can't decide which taffy to buy? We don’t blame you! That's why we offer the Taffy Shop "Create Your Own Assortment" options. Don't settle for just one flavor, you've got five full pounds of variety. Taffy Shop's salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

View AllClose

235 Reviews

  • 5
    CREATE YOUR OWN 5 LB MIX

    Posted by Kristin on 26th Oct 2018

    This is a great option for our office. Everyone can pick a favorite flavor or two and then we get a mix of only our favorites. Absolutely ideal! And the taffy is always so soft and chewy and plenty flavorful. We also love the little sample bag of taffy that gets include every time we order. This gives us a chance to try a few new flavors we wouldn't have otherwise tasted. I can't imagine getting my taffy from anywhere else.

  • 5
    Roseanna Stabile

    Posted by Roseanna Stabile on 1st Oct 2018

    Roseanna Stabile

  • 5
    5# create yourself

    Posted by Phillip K Glasser on 28th Sep 2018

    Great folks. Could not find flavor I wanted. Called left message. Monday go a call from Taffy Shop. She said they were running my choice Tuesday and if I could wait a day, they would include it in my order. I said okay. Following Tuesday we received our 5# bag with our choice flavor. Great product great people.

  • 5
    Eileen Gano

    Posted by Eileen Gano on 28th Sep 2018

    Love Taffy Shop! Every flavor is exactly as named or better!
    They were out of one of my flavor choices so they mixed the others evenly AND sent the.other when it was available—fantastic, thanks!

  • 5
    Best taffy ever. All the flavors I’ve ordered taste great.

    Posted by Sunny Perez on 23rd Sep 2018

    Taffy Shop was out of one of the flavors I ordered in five pound bag of pick your own flavors so they hand wrote a note in the bag they did send me telling of the problem and gave me half pound extra of another flavor and sent me the flavor I had ordered a few days later when it was in stock again. Great customer service!!!

  • 5
    Delicious

    Posted by Lisa on 20th Sep 2018

    I got this 5lb bag for my my nurse friends and I they all loveeeeeeee the taffy

  • 5
    taffy

    Posted by Jeff on 4th Sep 2018

    Great product. Thanks :-)

  • 5
    I love being able to choose!

    Posted by Shannon on 22nd Aug 2018

    This taffy is soft and delicious with just the right amount of chewiness! I love being able to choose which flavors I want, and all of the flavors in my mix tasted very true to the foods they are named for! I will definitely buy this again!

  • 5
    The taffy is wonderful.

    Posted by Judy Peterson on 20th Aug 2018

    The taffy was purchased for a party. It came right away, the order was correct, and the candy was delicious. Excellent service!

  • 5
    I love your Taffy as does my husband, I can't keep him out of it and have reordered twice in 2 months!!!

    Posted by Glenda Thompson on 13th Aug 2018

    Best Taffy EVER!!!!!

  • 5
    Dezere Shoop

    Posted by Dezere Shoop on 6th Aug 2018

    Everything tasted great. Also loved the sweet touch about of sending the birthday card! You guys are awesome!

  • 5
    Great stuff

    Posted by Rob on 2nd Aug 2018

    Best taffy we have ever had. Love the wild flavors. Better than silver dollar city taffy

View AllClose