Create Your Own 5 LB Mix

(359 reviews) Write a Review
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart


Can't decide which taffy to buy? We dont blame you! That's why we offer the Taffy Shop "Create Your Own Assortment" options. Don't settle for just one flavor, you've got five full pounds of variety. Taffy Shop's salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 300

View AllClose

359 Reviews

  • 5

    Posted by Molly Armstrong on 14th Oct 2021

    Great that you can pick your favorite flavors. Excellent taste too

  • 5

    Posted by Kelly on 3rd Oct 2021

    I love your taffy. The texture is perfect. A good chew, but soft too. The flavors are awesome. The only thing was I was disappointed there wasn’t vanilla to choose from this time. I especially like the small America bags of taffy. Our son is in the Navy and we sent a few bags to his landlord from Sicily. Thank you for making your products in the USA!

  • 5
    Great selection

    Posted by Gloria Lacaze on 2nd Oct 2021

    They are so good and so many flavors to choose from.

  • 4
    5 lb bag of Taffy

    Posted by Loretha White on 30th Sep 2021

    I purchase taffy frequently. I had to order something bit different because the flavor I enjoy was not available.

  • 5
    Best Taffy

    Posted by John Petraitis on 11th Sep 2021

    Taffy Shop saltwater taffy is the best that I’ve had because the different flavors actually taste like they’re supposed to. My one complaint is that they don’t have larger flavor assortments because I would like to try them all

  • 5
    Create a 5 Pound Bag

    Posted by Jan Kohler on 26th Jul 2021

    Absolutly fantastic. I cannot believe how good these are. Little thing. I live in europe and I was thinking that the delivery would take a while but nope. It arrived really fast, in less then a week I think. Fantastic service, fantastic candy, I will definitly shop here again.

  • 5
    5 pounder mix

    Posted by Stephanie Hadlow on 17th Jul 2021

    Absolutely the best taffy I have had. Being able to pick my own flavors was fabulous. The company was great when I had one flavor that was not available, but offered a change to me right away, so I would not have a delay in getting the product.

  • 5
    5 pound bag

    Posted by eileen sapaugh on 19th Jun 2021

    this is the best salt water taffy in the world! you have to get the 5 pound bag so you can pick 10 flavors! love it

  • 2
    Taffy was not fresh

    Posted by Melissa Hague on 27th May 2021

    Very disappointed the taffy that I ordered was hard, not fresh at all.

  • 2
    Taffies were bland and poor flavor. Would never order again. Threw them away!

    Posted by Rita Bergher on 22nd May 2021

    Not at all happy with my purchase. Taffies were bland, tasteless, and a bit bitter. Just would never order this again!!!!!

  • 5

    Posted by Jennifer on 14th May 2021

    This is some of the best taffy I've ever had. I'm definitely a customer for life.

  • 5
    5 pound create your own mix

    Posted by ellyn monroe on 14th May 2021

    I've tried several different brands (taffy is one of my favorite candies), and this was by far the best. The fresh orange had just the right amount of tang while the creamsicle/dreamsicle was smooth and creamy. Only a few of the pieces were melted/stuck to each other as well. Will def order again...also price was cheaper ordering direct then from outside source!

View AllClose