Create Your Own 5 LB Mix

(345 reviews) Write a Review
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart


Can't decide which taffy to buy? We dont blame you! That's why we offer the Taffy Shop "Create Your Own Assortment" options. Don't settle for just one flavor, you've got five full pounds of variety. Taffy Shop's salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 300

View AllClose

345 Reviews

  • 2

    Posted by on 18th Apr 2021

    The flavors were'nt as intense as I thought they would be

  • 5
    5 lb bag of raffy

    Posted by Chad vincent on 12th Apr 2021

    Some of the best taffy I have ever had

  • 5
    My picks!

    Posted by Azir Serinus on 26th Mar 2021

    The flavors are always topnotch! The bag is really nice and keeps it nice and dry, also looks great on the shelf.

  • 5
    The absolute best that I have ever had.

    Posted by Dianne G Collins on 25th Mar 2021

    I used to plan my vacations around places that had good Taffy shops. I don't have to worry about that anymore because I found the best online. And it was you! I have been all over the United States and then I found my favorite online. My kids can now go other places, no matter if they have Taffy stops or not.

  • 4
    5 lb. custom bag

    Posted by Sue Rindflesch on 20th Mar 2021

    fast service, fresh product, great selection, would have given 5 stars, but not all flavors are true.

  • 5
    Taffy I picked out

    Posted by Bernadette Treletsky on 20th Mar 2021

    I like this taffy because you can pick the kind you like and it is always fresh and tasty.

  • 5
    5 pound bag

    Posted by Eileen Sapaugh on 19th Mar 2021

    love this so I can get all my favorites in one bag

  • 5
    Love Love Love the create your own! I can get all my favorites witch I already have & try some new ones

    Posted by Unknown on 19th Mar 2021

    Aboustly love the flavors the strawberry cheese cake & whiped honey are my favorites and the taste is dead on!

  • 5
    Best Taffy in the World

    Posted by Alicia Willis on 19th Mar 2021

    I have bought several 5lb bags and have been very happy with all the different flavors I have chosen. Always delivered timely. I and my family have tried most of the flavors available and all are great. The taffy is soft and the flavor pops in your mouth. It is like having a flavorful party in your mouth. Best taffy I have ever eaten.

  • 5
    Love it!

    Posted by MarkeyMark on 18th Mar 2021

    So happy I found this site! Easy to make the perfect mix of my fav flavors! I’ll be back for more.

  • 4
    We did not get coffee flavor.

    Posted by Noah Brumfield on 14th Mar 2021

    All of the flavors are great but we did not get our coffee taffy that we ordered

  • 5
    Create your own 5lb bag

    Posted by Loretha White on 14th Mar 2021

    I love getting my own choices. It just seems some times it takes to long to get my product.

View AllClose