Create Your Own 5 LB Mix

(274 reviews) Write a Review
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart
$32.99

Description

Can't decide which taffy to buy? We dont blame you! That's why we offer the Taffy Shop "Create Your Own Assortment" options. Don't settle for just one flavor, you've got five full pounds of variety. Taffy Shop's salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 300

View AllClose

274 Reviews

  • 5
    Taffy

    Posted by Justin on 30th Mar 2020

    I was very satisfied with my 5 lbs bag of 10 different assorted taffy.

  • 5
    Rootbeer

    Posted by Connie on 26th Mar 2020

    It was delicous..

  • 5
    5lb bag

    Posted by Brad Felver on 15th Mar 2020

    Was delivered very quickly, and the flavors were incredible. Ordered again already.

  • 5
    Best Valentines Day gift!

    Posted by Vicki Dritschel on 22nd Feb 2020

    I purchased the custom mix for my husband for Valentines day instead of the usual chocolate and he LOVED it! He only likes the fruit flavors so I was happy I could choose which flavors were in the mix. I was not expecting the bag to be as giant as it was so it was a very pleasant surprise. He brings some taffy to work every day and the guys he works with ask him every day if they can have some. It is amazing taffy!! When this bag is done he already has a list of which flavors he wants to try next!

  • 5
    5 lbs selection

    Posted by DGA on 20th Feb 2020

    Once again could not wait to receive the taffy. My husband and I love it.

  • 5
    5 lb make my own mix

    Posted by Tammie Spegel-Day on 14th Feb 2020

    Worth every cent!! We order a 5 lb mix twice a year. The flavors are spectacular and better than anywhere else, bar none! Nicely packaged and arrives quickly!

  • 3
    taffy

    Posted by Cheryl Jarman on 10th Feb 2020

    The taffy is good. However, there are many flavors I do not like. I wish I didn't get so a big bag but it was the only way to try the flavors I wanted to try.

  • 5
    5lb create your own

    Posted by joyg42@hotmail.com on 7th Feb 2020

    This is awesome because you don't get any you don't like. I can't believe I didn't order any chocolate ones though. it is a lot of taffy though.

  • 5
    Best candy money can buy

    Posted by lloyd on 23rd Jan 2020

    Been eating salt water taffy for over 50 years and this company is one of the best.

  • 5
    Taffy

    Posted by Unknown on 20th Dec 2019

    Super Delicious!

  • 5
    Soft, fresh, and delicious!

    Posted by Shannon on 21st Nov 2019

    Soft, fresh, and delicious! My custom order arrived quickly and accurately and was everything I hoped for! I love being able to choose the flavors I want (though I wish they would bring back molasses since it's my favorite and offer some of the seasonal flavors like gingerbread!!)! I have order this several times and will continue to do so!

  • 5
    Custom mix taffy

    Posted by Mary on 14th Nov 2019

    Package received on time but the outer box was completely destroyed and taped up. But the taffy is delicious.! It was fresh, soft and true to flavor. The little taffy flavor charts is handy. I plan to have a taffy tasting contest at Thanksgiving!

View AllClose