null

Create Your Own 5 LB Mix

(312 reviews) Write a Review
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart
$32.99

Description

Can't decide which taffy to buy? We dont blame you! That's why we offer the Taffy Shop "Create Your Own Assortment" options. Don't settle for just one flavor, you've got five full pounds of variety. Taffy Shop's salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 300

View AllClose

312 Reviews

  • 4
    Peanut butter taffy

    Posted by Jeanne Westrate on 25th Oct 2020

    The flavor was good but inconsistent piece to piece. Some pieces I couldn't identify flavor until it was almost gone.

  • 4
    Amazing flavor a bit hard this batch tho

    Posted by James on 23rd Oct 2020

    Not my first time ordering I would have given 5 stars but this batch was a lot harder than my previous purchases unwrapping the taffy they shard apart otherwise I love them!

  • 5
    5lb bag of Taffy

    Posted by Jessica Wagenmaker on 8th Oct 2020

    This is hands down the best taffy on the planet. Soft and full of flavor. I love to create my own 5 lb mix bag with all the flavors we love best. When the shipment arrives at my door it feels like Christmas morning.

  • 5
    5 lb bag

    Posted by Susan Smith on 3rd Oct 2020

    Just as I ordered! All 10 flavors, all fresh, all delicious. And a great deal compared to the one pound price~

  • 5
    The best

    Posted by Angie W. on 3rd Oct 2020

    My family and I love taffy. This is the only place we order from. I love that I can choose our favorite flavors and get them delivered right to our door.

  • 5
    5 lb bag assortment

    Posted by Susan Charles on 2nd Oct 2020

    The taffy size is perfect to pop in your mouth during the day & the flavor released as it slowly dissolves in your mouth is delicious! Easy to take a few in your pocket on the run.

  • 5
    Taffy

    Posted by Leo Carmack on 24th Sep 2020

    I live in Michigan and Mackinac Island is noted for there taffy. I loved it and thought it was the best going. After trying your taffy there is no comparison at all. Yours is hands on the best. Unbelievable flavors. Everyone in my house is amazed of how true the flavors taste. Great job

  • 5
    Best taffy ever

    Posted by Ian Harris on 13th Sep 2020

    This is hands down the best taffy ever!!!! Amazing customer service!! I will be a life long customer!

  • 5
    5lbs Taffy

    Posted by Hayden on 13th Sep 2020

    Whats to say, if you like salt water taffy you can mix and match a whole lot of flavors. 10/10 would recommend.

  • 5
    (2) 5lb custom mix bags

    Posted by colin wyatt on 1st Sep 2020

    Best taffy I have ever had - its addictive! Also, the customer service is top notch - nice summer mix special!

  • 5
    5 lb bag.

    Posted by Elaine Witt on 23rd Aug 2020

    I love the “Create you bag” option... I can get all my favorite flavors ..... I share it with friends and family they love all the different flavors and also how fresh it is!

  • 5
    Creating a Mix

    Posted by Kris on 14th Aug 2020

    I LOVE this taffy and I am not a “taffy” kind of individual. With the “Mix Your Own”, I’ve been able to get my favorites (watermelon, apple, cherry, grape, key lime, and more!), avoid some not-so-favorite (crazy cotton candy and anything pumpkin), taste a couple of new ones via sample (strawberry something is delicious!)...amazing taffy, fresh, and delivered quickly. Plus, customer service is very responsive, kind, and helpful. Wonderful....& yummy

View AllClose