Create Your Own 5 LB Mix

(345 reviews) Write a Review
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Create Your Own 5 LB Assortment Salt Water Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Chart


Can't decide which taffy to buy? We dont blame you! That's why we offer the Taffy Shop "Create Your Own Assortment" options. Don't settle for just one flavor, you've got five full pounds of variety. Taffy Shop's salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 300

View AllClose

345 Reviews

  • 5

    Posted by Donna Lone on 10th Mar 2021

    Strawberry shortcake
    Blueberry muffin
    Birthday cake
    Pinata colada

  • 5
    Taffyshop taffy

    Posted by Jed grieve on 21st Feb 2021

    I love the taffyshop. Get flowers with a wide variety to choose from I'm looking forward to trying them all. After I finish the 5 pawned bag. And I live I Bever dam so that makes the taffyshop a Local company. Love to Local businesses.

  • 5
    Best Taffy EVER!!

    Posted by Erin on 18th Feb 2021

    This stuff is addicting! It's so good we cannot stop eating it.

  • 5
    Create your own 5 pounds

    Posted by Brenda Davies on 8th Feb 2021

    Creamy and delicious

  • 5

    Posted by Robert Sohns on 29th Jan 2021

    We were able to pick all of our old favorites as well as add a couple new ones. The product was excellent as usual and I’m sure the 5 lb. bag will be gone sone and we will be back for more. We are hooked!

  • 5

    Posted by Merrell Newbury on 18th Jan 2021

    It is the best taffy I've ever had every time I have ordered I have never been displeased.

  • 5
    Super delicious

    Posted by Judith Allen on 31st Dec 2020

    The best!

  • 3

    Posted by John Dent on 25th Dec 2020

    Dear Taffy Guy,

    I don't much care for the taffy I bought from you and won't be eating it. Don't get me wrong because it's probably good salt water taffy, but for me it's just a bit too salty. I'll give it away to friends and get their opinions, but it's a thumbs down or sideways thumb from me. It's ok, though, if it's the last bad purchase I ever make in this life then I'll have had a pretty easy go of it. I can't help but wonder, though, if your kitchen might have spilled the salt while mixing this batch. It's not as bad as swallowing a mouthful of ocean water while surfing, but it's close.

    Kind Regards,


  • 5
    Love their taffy!!!

    Posted by Michelle dewitt on 15th Dec 2020

    I was so happy to find this place online , you can create your own bag so every piece was fresh and delish!

  • 4

    Posted by on 13th Dec 2020


  • 5
    Delicious and fresh. Top notch Taffy

    Posted by michael on 13th Dec 2020

    This taffy never disappoints

  • 5

    Posted by Heather Zingg on 12th Dec 2020

    THIS is salt water taffy!! So often I buy salt water taffy at grocery stores and I'm always so disappointed with the taste. THIS is true, authentic salt water taffy! The key is it has just enough saltiness and chewiness! PERFECTION!

View AllClose