Create Your Own 1 LB Sugar Free Mix

(9 reviews) Write a Review
  • Create a 1 Pound Bag.  Choose up to 4 Sugar Free Flavors
  • Create Your Own 1 LB Sugar Free Mix
  • Create Your Own 1 LB Sugar Free Mix
  • Create a 1 Pound Bag.  Choose up to 4 Sugar Free Flavors
  • Create Your Own 1 LB Sugar Free Mix
  • Create Your Own 1 LB Sugar Free Mix


Do you have your favorite sugar-free flavors you just can't live without? That's why we offer the Taffy Shop "Create Your Own Assortment" options. Don't settle for just one flavor, you've got one full pound of variety. Taffy Shop's salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 60

Ingredients: Malitol syrup, coconut oil, sea salt, egg whites, evaporated milk, artificial flavor, natural flavor, malic acid, artificial color, artificial color (including FD&C blue 1, red 2, red 3, red 40, yellow 5, yellow 6).

View AllClose

9 Reviews

  • 5
    Tastes great nice and soft. Quick delivery

    Posted by Doreen on 18th Sep 2020

    Excellent taffy

  • 5
    Great sugar free taffy

    Posted by Doreen on 7th Sep 2020

    Excellent. Soft and tasty

  • 4

    Posted by Barbara J. Loomis on 5th Sep 2020

    I love the taffy but the last batch was very sticky. I had a hard time getting the paper wrap off without leaving some of the taffy

  • 5
    Great product

    Posted by Unknown on 21st Jul 2020

    Great clean flavors, no noticable artificial sweetener taste. Shipping is super fast!

  • 5
    Sugarfree taffy

    Posted by Stephanie Gohr on 25th Jan 2020

    I recently purchase a 1 lb bag of sugar free taffy and the flavor was amazing! I highly recommend this taffy to anyone that is considering trying. Just like with all sugar free candy you can’t over indulge due to the sugar alcohols but you are very temped too! Great flavor excellent salt water taffy!

  • 5

    Posted by Jessica on 7th Jun 2018

    This laffy taffy is delicious and to be in sugar free is great thank you!

  • 5
    Sugar free assorted

    Posted by Veronica Abshire on 28th Jan 2018

    This sugar free taffy is by far the best we have ever had. Will definitely order again. Only wish there were more flavors in sugar free.

  • 5

    Posted by Rhonda on 17th Jul 2016

    I have bought salt water taffy from a few different companies & Taffy Shop is by far the best deal. All the taffy I bought has been wonderful. This is the only place I got taffy where I can choose what flavors I want.
    This time, I bought sugar free for my Father-in-Law and the only issue I had was the color of the sugar free is different from the regular, leading me to believe they sent the wrong flavor. Customer service was very helpful & explained this.
    Shipping was very fast & a reasonable rate. Will always buy my taffy from them.

  • 5
    Very good taffy!

    Posted by Unknown on 6th Sep 2015

    It was very good, The only thing, we had to leave it in the refrigerator, which was fine bc it wasn't hard.

View AllClose