Create Your Own 2 LB Sugar Free Mix

(23 reviews) Write a Review
  • Create a 2 Pound Bag.  Choose up to 6 Sugar Free Flavors
  • Create Your Own 2 LB Sugar Free Mix
  • Create Your Own 2 LB Sugar Free Mix
  • Create a 2 Pound Bag.  Choose up to 6 Sugar Free Flavors
  • Create Your Own 2 LB Sugar Free Mix
  • Create Your Own 2 LB Sugar Free Mix


Do you have your favorite sugar-free flavors you just can't live without? That's why we offer the Taffy Shop "Create Your Own Assortment" options. Don't settle for just one flavor, you've got two full pounds of variety. Taffy Shop's salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 120

Ingredients: Malitol syrup, coconut oil, sea salt, egg whites, evaporated milk, artificial flavor, natural flavor, malic acid, artificial color, artificial color (including FD&C blue 1, red 2, red 3, red 40, yellow 5, yellow 6).

View AllClose

23 Reviews

  • 5
    Sugar free taffy

    Posted by Jon on 15th Jul 2021

    This sugar free taffy is the best. I will definitely be ordering this again.

  • 5
    Taffy purchase

    Posted by Chris on 10th Jul 2021

    Great tasting sugarfree. So happy to eat something so delicious and sugarfree. Would highly recommend. Best salt water taffy!

  • 5
    Delicious and fresh

    Posted by MC Freeman on 21st Jun 2021

    The whole family is enjoying the sugar free taffy

  • 5
    SF taffy

    Posted by Karen Smeltz on 4th Jun 2021

    I love these. Being able to choose your flavors is great
    The taste and freshness is the best taffy I've ever had.

  • 5
    Fantastic !

    Posted by Rhonda on 30th May 2021

    Delicious, fresh and soft sugar free taffy ! My go to store now !

  • 5
    ordered both regular and sugar free. Can't tell the difference!

    Posted by Susan on 28th Apr 2021

    Haven't had taffy this good since Atlantic City.

  • 5
    Sugar Free Taffy

    Posted by Virginia E Leach on 22nd Apr 2021

    The sugar free taffy is great. My kids even love it.

  • 5
    Doesn’t taste sugar free

    Posted by Molly R on 21st Feb 2021

    The 2 pound create your own mix allows a choice of 6 different flavors. The sugar free taffy tastes just as good as the regular but the flavor selection is much more limited. Be warned: if you order strawberry and cinnamon, you won’t be able to tell the difference visually as they are both pink. Vanilla is the absolute tastiest, cinnamon second, in my opinion. Also note: the sugar free are not that much lower in calories than the regular.

  • 2
    2 lb. custom bag of sugar free taffy

    Posted by Linda Icenhour on 15th Feb 2021

    I had picked 6 flavors. About3/4 of the bag seems to be all one flavor. I could find none of the black licorice, and there were only four pieces of the banana flavor. Also, a greater choice of flavors would be nice—-maybe lime or peppermint.

  • 5
    2 lb make your own mix

    Posted by Michael Thomas on 16th Oct 2020

    Loved it. A little bit of everything. Even though they ran out of one flavor just before shipping.

  • 5
    sugar free taffy

    Posted by Gary Yarbrough on 16th Oct 2020

    Great. Need more sugar-free flavors!!!

  • 5
    Best taffy

    Posted by Barbara J. Loomis on 18th Aug 2020

    Love this taffy,especially the licorice, cinnamon and chocolate

View AllClose