Dessert Flavors

You know what's better than getting a Banana Creme Pie thrown in your face? Getting a piece of our gourmet Banana Dream Pie taffy in your mouth. Trust us. Taffy Shop's Banana Dream Pie salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Remember that time you got straight A's and your Dad took you out to celebrate over banana splits? Our gourmet Banana Split salt water taffy tastes just like that! A+! Taffy Shop's Banana Split salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the...

Happy Birthday to you! Happy Birthday to you! Oh wait, it's not your birthday? Celebrate anyway with some gourmet Birthday Cake Cake taffy. Taffy Shop's Birthday Cake Cake salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Would you like to order some dessert? Our gourmet Caramel Cheesy Cake taffy is the perfect beginning, middle, and end to any meal. Taffy Shop's Caramel Cheesy Cake salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

One of our most favorite things when we were kids was the Halloween carnival. It had games, prizes, costumes, and best of all, caramel popcorn. Those carnivals were totally the inspiration for our gourmet Caramel Popcorn Ball salt water taffy. So, throw...

Chocolate + Caramel + Latte = three of the best things ever mixed together to make one incredible piece of gourmet taffy. Order some, you can check our math. Taffy Shop's Chocolate Caramel Latte salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the...

If you're like us, you have very little patience when it comes to waiting for cinnamon buns to rise, bake, and cool off before you gobble them up. This is one of the main reasons we created our gourmet Cinnamon Bun taffy. All you have to do is unwrap it...

Finally, after years of experimenting to create the perfect coffee flavored candy, we ecstatically introduce the World's Best Coffee Saltwater Taffy.  No seriously, coffee candy is one of our most requested items.  You already know that we have...

We know, we know, you're gramgram made the best chocolate chip cookies of all time. But guess what? We make the best Cookie Dough gourmet taffy of all time. Just sayin'. Taffy Shop's Cookie Dough salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in...

Our Dessert Assortment is the perfect mix of our favorite dessert flavored taffies.Flavors include: Strawberry Cheesy Cake, Caramel Cheesy Cake, Granny's Apple Pie, Banana Dream Pie, Campfire S'mores, Red Velvet Batter, Key Lime Pie, Birthday Cake Cake,...

Hey Buddy, why don't you wander on up to this here soda fountain and order yourself a creamy root beer float? This is exactly what you'll be thinking when you try our gourmet Frosty Root Beer Float taffy. Taffy Shop's Frosty Root Beer Float salt water...

Our gourmet Granny's Apple Pie taffy tastes like all of your best summer picnics combined into one, little bite. Taffy Shop's Granny's Apple Pie salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Our gourmet Key Lime Pie taffy is as tart as it is tasty. And it's a really awesome green color. Taffy Shop's Key Lime Pie salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Hey, here's a good idea! Don't bake an entire pie. Just unwrap a piece of gourmet Lemon Meringue Pie taffy. It'll save you a lot of work and the clean-up is super easy. Taffy Shop's Lemon Meringue Pie salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love...

Wouldn't it be awesome to have a time machine that would take you back in time to your favorite 50's drive-thru, so you could order an authentic chocolate malt? If your answer is yes, then you should immediately purchase some of our gourmet Malted...

Look out! This gourmet taffy is a triple threat full of strawberry, chocolate, and vanilla flavor. Taffy Shop's Neapolitan salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

There are few things as refreshing as the sweet taste of peaches mixed with delicious cream, which is why we mixed them together to make this gourmet taffy. Taffy Shop's Peaches and Cream salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Soon to be one of your favorite new flavors, our Peanut Butter Taffy uses a special blend of flavoring to create that peanut butter flavor while still being nut-free. Taffy Shop's salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA. Please...

Take a step back to your childhood when you lived on Peanut Butter & Jelly sandwiches all summer long. Our PB & J taffy combines that delicious peanut butter flavor with a hint of grape jelly. Just like mom used to make! Taffy Shop's salt water...

Everybody knows the best part of Thanksgiving dinner is the pumpkin pie. The best thing about our gourmet Pumpkin Spice taffy is that you don't have to wait for Thanksgiving to eat it. It's available all year long. Taffy Shop's Pumpkin Spice salt water...

Our Red Velvet gourmet taffy is tastier and far more charming than Rhett Butler himself. Taffy Shop's Red Velvet Batter salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Just like grandma used to make, our Spiced Carrot Cake taffy is rich in flavor. Enjoy the delicious spices combined with a hint of cream cheese frosting. Taffy Shop's salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

It stands to reason that if you're a lover of cheesecake and strawberries, you'll love our Strawberry Cheesy Cake gourmet taffy. You can't argue our logic. Taffy Shop's Strawberry Cheesy Cake salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the...