Novelty Flavors

Novelty Flavors

  • Birthday Cake Cake Salt Water Taffy Birthday Cake Cake

    Birthday Cake Cake

    As low as $4.59
    Happy Birthday to you! Happy Birthday to you! Oh wait, it's not your birthday? Celebrate anyway with some gourmet Birthday Cake Cake taffy. Taffy Shop's Birthday Cake Cake salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA. Approximate...
    As low as $4.59
  • Black Licorice Salt Water Taffy Black Licorice

    Black Licorice

    As low as $4.59
    What's black and white and delicious all over? Our gourmet Black Licorice flavored taffy! Taffy Shop's Black Licorice salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA. Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 1/2 lb - 27 pieces 1 lb - 54 pieces 2...
    As low as $4.59
  • Blueberry Muffin Crumb Salt Water Taffy Blueberry Muffin Crumb

    Blueberry Muffin Crumb

    As low as $4.59
    Wake up and say good morning because our Blueberry Muffin Crumb gourmet taffy tastes just like one of those extra special days when you wake up to the delicious smell of blueberry muffins baking in the oven. Taffy Shop's Blueberry Muffin Crumb salt water...
    As low as $4.59
  • Bubble Gum Salt Water Taffy Bubble Gum

    Bubble Gum

    As low as $4.59
    We know it's stretchy and that it tastes just like bubble gum, but we do not recommend blowing bubbles with our gourmet taffy. Trust us, we've tried and the results weren't pretty. Taffy Shop's Bubble Gum salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with...
    As low as $4.59
  • Butter Rum Salt Water Taffy Butter Rum

    Butter Rum

    As low as $4.59
    Yo ho, yo ho delicious Butter Rum flavored gourmet taffy for me! Well, actually it's for you, but you can see where we were going with this. Taffy Shop's Butter Rum salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA. Approximate Pieces Per...
    As low as $4.59
  • Caliente Cayenne Salt Water Taffy Caliente Cayenne

    Caliente Cayenne

    As low as $4.59
    Just as its name implies, this taffy is extreme and it's hot...it is Caliente Cayenne! Looking for something a bit different? This taffy with a hot twist might just be for you. Taffy Shop's Caliente Cayenne salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with...
    As low as $4.59
  • Campfire S'mores Salt Water Taffy Campfire S'mores

    Campfire S'mores

    As low as $4.59
    No tents, no campfires, no problem! Now you can enjoy s'mores in the comfort of your own home year-round! Taffy Shop's Campfire S'mores salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA. Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 1/2 lb - 30 pieces 1...
    As low as $4.59
  • Candy Corn Salt Water Taffy Candy Corn

    Candy Corn

    As low as $4.59
    Trick or treat! You're so neat! We'll give you something good to eat, like our mouthwatering, gourmet Candy Corn taffy! Taffy Shop's Candy Corn salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA. Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 1/2 lb - 30...
    As low as $4.59
  • Chili Mango Madness Salt Water Taffy Chili Mango Madness

    Chili Mango Madness

    As low as $4.59
    An interesting combination no doubt, but a tasty treat for sure. Who would've thought chili and mango could work so well together? We did! Taffy Shop's Chili Mango Madness salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA. Approximate...
    As low as $4.59
  • Cinnamon Swirl Salt Water Taffy Cinnamon

    Cinnamon

    As low as $4.59
    This taffy has a perfect sweet and creamy cinnamon taste. In other words, it's a perfectly pink piece of heaven. Taffy Shop's Cinnamon salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA. Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 1/2 lb - 30 pieces 1...
    As low as $4.59
  • Cinnamon Bun Salt Water Taffy Cinnamon Bun

    Cinnamon Bun

    As low as $4.59
    If you're like us, you have very little patience when it comes to waiting for cinnamon buns to rise, bake, and cool off before you gobble them up. This is one of the main reasons we created our gourmet Cinnamon Bun taffy. All you have to do is unwrap it...
    As low as $4.59
  • Coffee Salt Water Taffy Coffee

    Coffee

    As low as $4.59
    Finally, after years of experimenting to create the perfect coffee-flavored candy, we ecstatically introduce the World's Best Coffee salt water taffy.  No seriously, coffee candy is one of our most requested items.  You already know that we...
    As low as $4.59
  • Creamy Eggnog Salt Water Taffy Creamy Eggnog

    Creamy Eggnog

    As low as $4.59
    All the great flavor of a classic eggnog, without the milk mustache. Taffy Shop's Creamy Eggnog salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA. Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 1/2 lb - 30 pieces 1 lb - 60 pieces 2 lbs - 120 pieces 5...
    As low as $4.59
  • Flavored Lemonade Assortment Salt Water Taffy Flavored Lemonade Mix

    Flavored Lemonade Mix

    As low as $4.59
    Nothing quenches your thirst on a hot day like an ice cold lemonade. We've combined some of our favorite flavors to create our new totally rad Flavored Lemonades. Enjoy Raspberry Lemonade, Peach Lemonade, Cherry Limeade and Strawberry Lemonade...
    As low as $4.59
  • Frosty Root Beer Float Salt Water Taffy Frosty Root Beer Float

    Frosty Root Beer Float

    As low as $4.59
    Hey Buddy, why don't you wander on up to this here soda fountain and order yourself a creamy root beer float? This is exactly what you'll be thinking when you try our gourmet Frosty Root Beer Float taffy. Taffy Shop's Frosty Root Beer Float salt water...
    As low as $4.59
  • Maple Salt Water Taffy Maple

    Maple

    As low as $4.59
    You don't have to be Canadian to love our gourmet Maple taffy. You just have to be human and love delicious things. Taffy Shop's Maple salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA. Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 1/2 lb - 30 pieces 1...
    As low as $4.59
  • Maple Bacon Salt Water Taffy Maple Bacon

    Maple Bacon

    As low as $4.59
    Your eyes do not deceive! There is no denying that bacon makes everything better, including our deliciously unique Maple Bacon taffy! Are those pink lines in the taffy real bacon? No, but I dare you to tell the difference. Taffy Shop's Maple Bacon salt...
    As low as $4.59
  • Peanut Butter Salt Water Taffy Peanut Butter

    Peanut Butter

    As low as $4.59
    Soon to be one of your favorite new flavors, our Peanut Butter flavored taffy uses a special blend of flavoring to create that peanut butter flavor while still being peanut-free. Taffy Shop's salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the...
    As low as $4.59
  • PB&J Salt Water Taffy Peanut Butter & Jelly

    Peanut Butter & Jelly

    As low as $4.59
    Take a step back to your childhood when you lived on Peanut Butter & Jelly sandwiches all summer long. Our PB & J taffy combines that delicious peanut butter flavor with a hint of grape jelly. Just like mom used to make! Taffy Shop's salt water...
    As low as $4.59
  • Rad Raspberry Lemonade Salt Water Taffy Rad Raspberry Lemonade

    Rad Raspberry Lemonade

    As low as $4.59
    What do you get when you mix sweet raspberries with tart lemonade? A sweet and sassy gourmet taffy! Taffy Shop's Rad Raspberry Lemonade salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA. Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 1/2 lb - 30 pieces 1...
    As low as $4.59
  • Red Candy Apple Salt Water Taffy Red Candy Apple

    Red Candy Apple

    As low as $4.59
    Step right up, ladies and gents, and get a taste of our delightfully red, deliciously green, gourmet candy apple taffy. Taffy Shop's Red Candy Apple salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA. Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 1/2 lb -...
    As low as $4.59
  • Red Licorice Salt Water Taffy Red Licorice

    Red Licorice

    As low as $4.59
    Our gourmet red licorice taffy has that delicious, old-timey taste without the hassle of having to take your buggy to the general store. Taffy Shop's Red Licorice salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA. Approximate Pieces Per...
    As low as $4.59
  • Spiced Carrot Cake Salt Water Taffy Spiced Carrot Cake

    Spiced Carrot Cake

    As low as $4.59
    Just like grandma used to make, our Spiced Carrot Cake taffy is rich in flavor. Enjoy the delicious spices combined with a hint of cream cheese frosting. Taffy Shop Spiced Carrot Cake salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA...
    As low as $4.59
  • Whipped Honey Salt Water Taffy Whipped Honey

    Whipped Honey

    As low as $4.59
    Oh honey! This gourmet taffy is totally tasty! Taffy Shop's Whipped Honey salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA. Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 1/2 lb - 30 pieces 1 lb - 60 pieces 2 lbs - 120 pieces 5 lbs - 300 pieces
    As low as $4.59