Sweet Molasses

(9 reviews) Write a Review
0.51 LBS
Calculated at Checkout
  • Sweet Molasses Salt Water Taffy
  • Sweet Molasses
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Guide
  • Sweet Molasses Salt Water Taffy
  • Sweet Molasses
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Guide


We'd like to say that it will take you as long as it took us to pour the molasses into our gourmet recipe to eat this taffy, but it's so yummy that you'll probably eat it quite quickly. Taffy Shop's Sweet Molasses salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

View AllClose

9 Reviews

  • 5
    Wonderful Flavor

    Posted by M. McGee on 8th Sep 2017

    This is one of my two favorite flavors from the Taffy Shop. This traditional flavor has a true molasses taste without being overwhelming.

  • 5

    Posted by FRANKIE N DEFORD on 11th Feb 2017


  • 5
    Should be 10 Stars!!

    Posted by Frankie DeFord on 15th Sep 2016

    Perfect as always. I am addicted to molasses!

  • 5
    Winner by a Landslide!!

    Posted by Frankie on 1st Aug 2016

    Molasses taffy is so hard to find. This is the best I have ever had. It's soft and melts in your mouth. I have to restrain myself from ripping open the bag as soon as it gets here. Just doesn't last long enough! It IS my number 1 all-time favorite taffy. Try it...you will be hooked on molasses for life!

  • 5

    Posted by Unknown on 11th May 2015


  • 5

    Posted by Unknown on 20th Oct 2014

    This has to be the freshest, most delicious taffy EVER!
    I found your taffy at a candy shop while traveling. Sadly returning to that store was not possible and then I discovered you online!
    I will be a forever customer!
    Thank you for you fabulous products AND service!

  • 5
    best taffy ever

    Posted by lennie on 7th Aug 2014

    Since I was a little girl I've always loved mollases taffy so when I found the Taffy Shop it just made since to order a bunch. Now it's an addiction, sorry to say but hey, it could be worse. I will always be a customer.

  • 5
    im addicted forever. keep them coming!

    Posted by lennie on 6th Jun 2014

    Love mollases taffy and have since I was a little girl. Hard to find now days but now that I know where they are, beware!

  • 5
    Grandma's favorite

    Posted by Danielle Lewis on 22nd Dec 2013

    This is my grandma's favorite flavor of taffy. It's hard to find in my area, so I had to look online. Glad I picked the Taffy Shop, because they taffy was great, reasonably priced, and arrived quickly.

View AllClose