Sweet Peppermint Taffy

(28 reviews) Write a Review
  • Sweet Peppermint Salt Water Taffy
  • Sweet Peppermint Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Guide
  • Sweet Peppermint Salt Water Taffy
  • Sweet Peppermint Taffy
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Guide


Peppermint Taffy

Our gourmet Sweet Peppermint taffy tastes better than Christmas morning. Don't believe us? You might just be put on Santa's naughty list. Taffy Shop's Sweet Peppermint salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Approximate Pieces Per Bag:

  • 1/2 lb - 30 pieces
  • 1 lb - 60 pieces
  • 2 lbs - 120 pieces
  • 5 lbs - 300 pieces
View AllClose

28 Reviews

  • 4
    Tastes more like spearmint than peppermint

    Posted by Karen Houser on 4th Sep 2021

    I've ordered the sweet peppermint several times and have always been very pleased with it, but, although it identifies it as sweet peppermint, to me it tastes more like spearmint.

  • 5
    Yummy Peppermint

    Posted by on 27th Aug 2021

    The best salt water taffy ever!!

  • 4
    Sweet Peppermint

    Posted by Karen Houser on 20th Jun 2021

    I've purchased this flavor from you in the past and like it very much. It is classic peppermint.

  • 5
    I'm addicted to this taffy!

    Posted by Anne Marie Heller on 9th May 2021

    The Sweet Peppermint taffy is my favorite by far. I'm totally addicted. The other flavors are also very good, but Sweet Peppermint is my absolute favorite.

  • 5
    Best Peppermint Taffy

    Posted by Lynley Sharp on 5th Feb 2021

    This is the best I've had from a variety of sources in the US. I love it so much, my order gets bigger every time. We've eaten 3 lbs of it in about 4 months. Can't get enough! Great place to start if you're new to taffy.

  • 5
    Peppermint taffy

    Posted by Anne on 17th Dec 2020

    The best taffy I've ever had!

  • 2
    Peppermint Disappointment

    Posted by Christopher Wade on 29th Nov 2020

    I'd like to first say I like Taffy Shop itself, lots of interesting flavors, and although it's prohibitively expensive you DO ship to Japan, which is rare and welcome.

    Because the overseas shipping is so pricey (not the Taffy Shop's fault, prices are high everywhere), I went all out and bought three 5-pound bags of taffy, two of Sweet Peppermint and one Favorites Mixed bag.

    Which is why, with fully 10 pounds of Sweet Peppermint in front of me, I'm sad to say it's the first time I've ever not loved it, and I've tried taffy from a half dozen shops and companies. The problem (and it carries over to all the other flavors as well) is that the specific flavoring is too weak and the base taffy far too buttery-tasting. I get 90% sweet butter and 10% peppermint, which is terrible. I tried Sweet Peppermint, Very Vanilla, Creamy Caramel, and S'mores, and could hardly tell the difference at all. If I hadn't looked at them first, I wouldn't have been able to identify a single one from taste alone. The additive flavoring needs to be much, much stronger, as the base taffy's almost butterscotch level taste overpowers everything else.

    The texture is fine, but after spending almost $300 USD to get these giant bags over to Japan, I wanted several kilograms of PEPPERMINT candies to enjoy over the holidays, not sugar-butter. The taffy is not objectively bad by any means, just not at all to my personal liking.

  • 5
    Sweet Peppermint

    Posted by Laura Cacia on 1st Aug 2020

    This is the flavor that sold me on Biting into the peppermint taffy reminds me of Christmas. My very favorite!

  • 5
    My favorite

    Posted by on 10th Jul 2020

    I love these even when restaurants offer em their delicious

  • 5
    found it nice and chewy with a delicious flavor but personal preference would be a slightly stronger peppermint flavor

    Posted by lynne anderson on 31st Oct 2019

    will continue to buy

  • 5
    Sweet Pepperment is the best!

    Posted by Walt Kellcy on 23rd May 2019

    I used to get a sample pack of different flavors with each order? Has that stopped?

  • 5
    Sweet Pepperment loved in Seattle

    Posted by Walt Kellcy on 2nd Nov 2018

    This is the best, freshest, most authentic of all peppermint taffy's! Keep it coming...

View AllClose