Taffy Shop's Favorites Mix

(123 reviews) Write a Review
  • Taffy Shop Favorites Salt Water Taffy Mix
  • Taffy Shop's Favorites Mix
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Guide
  • Taffy Shop Favorites Salt Water Taffy Mix
  • Taffy Shop's Favorites Mix
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Guide


You know what they say: sweets for the sweet. Give someone sweet in your life this delicious assortment of gourmet salt water taffy. This mix includes 22 of our top selling flavors, including Rad Raspberry, Grape Grape, Cinnamon, Fresh Strawberry, Pineapple Whip, Blueberry Blast, Lemon Meringue, Fresh Orange, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Granny Apple, Frosty Root Beer Float, Rad Raspberry Lemonade, Wild Watermelon, Creamy Caramel, Banana Dream, Birthday Cake Cake, Very Vanilla, Sweet Peppermint, Whipped Chocolate, Cherry Cherry, Campfire S'mores, and Juicy Pear.

Taffy Shop's Favorites Mix salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Approximate Pieces Per Bag:

  • 1/2 lb - 30 pieces
  • 1 lb - 60 pieces
  • 2 lbs - 120 pieces
  • 5 lbs - 300 pieces

Please note: This mix is combined in large batches, so each bag might not contain all flavors. If you are looking for specific flavors in equal weights, choose your own combination with our "Create Your Own Mix" bags. 


View AllClose

123 Reviews

  • 2
    Favorites Mix

    Posted by Jennifer Brown on 10th Jan 2021

    We got zero pieces of sweet peppermint, cinnamon, and banana dream. Four other flavors only had 1 piece each. (7 of juicy pear.) Disappointing when we got the bag so we could try different flavors and missed out completely on 3 of them. :/

  • 5
    Favorites mix

    Posted by Terry Gonzales on 19th Dec 2020

    It was really good! I haven’t had saltwater taffy in a long time. It was a nice surprise.

  • 5
    Best flavors - Soft Taffy

    Posted by Katie Sampedro on 19th Dec 2020

    Delicious - delectable - I grew up in NJ and always had Jersey Shore Salt Water Taffy - these recon better. We love every flavor in the favorites mix and we’re going to keep a bag and gift a bag - but we ate them both! So good.

  • 5
    Taffy Shops Favorites

    Posted by Bobbi on 16th Dec 2020

    This is the best taffy. The product is tasty and the people are so kind. It was packaged and shipped fast but the only negative thing I will say is this mix was missing nine flavors that was said to be in the bag. That is why I ordered this mix and unfortunately the flavors I really wanted were the nine missing. There were no added flavors to replace them but all in all it’s great taffy.

  • 2
    Mixed taffy, but frustratingly similar taste

    Posted by Christopher Wade on 29th Nov 2020

    The base taffy used at Taffy is strong and buttery, which may be to your liking. Unfortunately the individual flavorings are very weak, so it's hard to tell the flavors apart. I wish they were more distinctive and the common base less buttery tasting.

  • 5
    flavor and texture

    Posted by paul nelson on 21st Nov 2020

    The best; by any stretch of the taffy.

  • 5

    Posted by Tonia McCalvin on 29th Sep 2020


  • 5
    Everything about this was great!

    Posted by MARK AUSTIN on 24th Sep 2020

    I am super excited about this. There was some user error on my part, I reached out to the team there. Erin was so helpful and kind! Got everything straightened out. The taffy is amazing. Highly recommend!!

  • 4
    Favorites Mix

    Posted by Cindy on 20th Sep 2020

    Although these are not the same flavors that we got in our favorites mix, it was still a good mix of flavors. One of the nice things is getting a chart to find out what the flavors are. However, it would be even better if it was actual pictures of the candy, because sometimes it is very difficult to tell the difference in the chart that is sent. These flavors are not all my favorites, but still a good mix.

  • 5

    Posted by Amanda Windschitl on 5th Sep 2020

    I love the flavor of your taffy! I can taste the salt and they taste fresh! I’ve never had a hard taffy when ordering from the taffy shop. Love love love

  • 5
    Taffy Shop's Favorite Mix is Awesome!

    Posted by Debbie Sutyak on 22nd Aug 2020

    Love this assortment of taffy! So many different and delicious flavors! Smooth and melts in your mouth. I highly recommend Favorites Mix Taffy!

  • 5
    Taffy Favorites

    Posted by Angella Sears on 16th Aug 2020


View AllClose