Taffy Shop's Favorites Mix

(90 reviews) Write a Review
0.51 LBS
Calculated at Checkout
  • Taffy Shop Favorites Salt Water Taffy Mix
  • Taffy Shop's Favorites Mix
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Guide
  • Taffy Shop Favorites Salt Water Taffy Mix
  • Taffy Shop's Favorites Mix
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Guide


You know what they say: sweets for the sweet. Give someone sweet in your life this assorted and delicious mix of gourmet salt water taffy. This mix includes 22 of our top selling flavors, including Rad Raspberry, Grape, Cinnamon, Strawberry, Pineapple, Blueberry Blast, Lemon Meringue, Orange, Chocolate Chip Cookie, Green Apple, Root Beer Float, Raspberry Lemonade, Wild Watermelon, Caramel Swirl, Banana Dream, Birthday Cake Cake, Very Vanilla, Peppermint, Whipped Chocolate, Cherry Cherry, S'mores and Golden Pear.

Taffy Shop's Assorted Mix salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

 *Taffy Shop salt water taffy is magically delicious! No, we aren't talking about that cereal with purple horseshoes....  But sometimes our taffy plays Houdini and disappears before the next batch is ready!  If this happens to a flavor or two in this mix, we will kindly replace the flavor(s) with some other favorites to enjoy!  

View AllClose

90 Reviews

  • 5
    Best Taffy and Service Bar None

    Posted by Tom DeHart on 19th Aug 2016

    I just found out about the Taffy Shop a few weeks ago and have already ordered 5-6 pounds. While I don't have a favorite flavor, I usually order the one pound "Taffy Shop Favorites Assortment" to get most one of every flavor and then another pound of whatever catches my eye that day....usually some combination of chocolates.

  • 5
    Best Taffy

    Posted by Unknown on 15th Aug 2016

    While visiting in California, we stopped at a candy store that sold this terrific taffy. This is better than any taffy we have ever had! Delish!!

  • 5
    Wonderful product!

    Posted by Tom DeHart on 11th Aug 2016

    It has only been 10 days since I ordered my first one pound "favorites assortment" and today I have only 6 pieces of taffy left. I have already reordered but two pounds this time. I am almost 75 years old and I have eaten a LOT of taffy over the years but this is BY FAR the best I have ever found. Thank you Taffy Shop!!!

  • 4

    Posted by Terry Wright on 9th Apr 2016

    The tin is very nice. Wish that Made in Alaska was printed on it.

    The free samples were yummy. The tin is a gift :)

  • 5
    Good Stuff!!

    Posted by Onehappycustomer on 31st Mar 2016

    I'm very pleased with the product and I've decided to use these yummy treats at my upcoming wedding. I'm getting ready to place another order just for myself. Oh and it ships very quickly! So yet another thumbs up fr me :)

  • 5

    Posted by Latisha on 20th Mar 2016

    I ordered a batch of taffy for party favors and I don't think it was a good idea for me to bag them up, now I'm short of supply due to tasting all the flavors! I've put in another order and I will continue to place my orders for future events and or maybe just to keep in my candy bowl :) I definitely recommend this product to others. My favorite flavors so far are vanilla and cotton candy but I still have many others to taste so I'm looking forward to my next delivery!

  • 5
    Love this taffy!

    Posted by Unknown on 11th Dec 2015

    I first discovered this taffy at the Ohio State fair. I loved it so much I decided to try and find its origin on line. I have been buying it ever since. It's so much better than any other taffy I have ever tried.

  • 5

    Posted by Audrey on 11th Oct 2015

    Creamy melt in your mouth goodness. You cant just eat one piece it very addicting. Will be ordering more very soon. Great customer service.

  • 5
    WOW !

    Posted by joan on 17th Sep 2015

    best taffy I've had in a long time

  • 5

    Posted by Unknown on 11th Sep 2015

    I ordered this Taffy as a "tester" for party favors I'm doing. It will work out perfectly for what I have planned. The Taffy arrived a few days after I ordered it, fresh, soft and delicious. The "favorites" assortment that I received gave me the perfect sampling of the many flavors that are available. I especially appreciated the enclosed guide with pictures and flavors. Looking forward placing my order for the holidays! THANK YOU TAFFY SHOP...

  • 5
    taffy assortment

    Posted by Dianne Cross on 13th Aug 2015

    I have ordered Taffy from here several times now. I noticed this assortment was on sale so ordered a 5lb bag. The taffy is still the best I've had but this batch was a little stale, not the very soft texture I'm used to getting here. That probably explains why it was on sale. All in all, still the best taffy around.

  • 5
    Great taffy

    Posted by John Brewster on 3rd Aug 2015

    I have ordered there before and love the taffy.They get your order out fast and it's fresh and good.I will order from them again.

View AllClose