Valentine's Day

Valentine's Day

  • Caliente Cayenne Salt Water Taffy Caliente Cayenne

    Caliente Cayenne

    As low as $4.59
    Just as its name implies, this taffy is extreme and it's hot...it is Caliente Cayenne! Looking for something a bit different? This taffy with a hot twist might just be for you. Taffy Shop's Caliente Cayenne salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with...
    As low as $4.59
  • Cinnamon Swirl Salt Water Taffy Cinnamon

    Cinnamon

    As low as $4.59
    This taffy has a perfect sweet and creamy cinnamon taste. In other words, it's a perfectly pink piece of heaven. Taffy Shop's Cinnamon salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA. Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 1/2 lb - 30 pieces 1...
    As low as $4.59
  • Cran-Raspberry Salt Water Taffy Cran-Raspberry

    Cran-Raspberry

    As low as $4.59
    We've tried to mix a lot of flavors together at the Taffy Shop and some are more successful than others. Case in point: our Cran-Raspberry salt water taffy. It's sweet and fruity and just a little tart. It's far more tasty than that time we tried to mix...
    As low as $4.59
  • Crazy Cotton Candy Salt Water Taffy Crazy Cotton Candy

    Crazy Cotton Candy

    As low as $4.59
    Remember that time your family went to the circus and your parents bought you your very own cotton candy that you didn't have to share with anyone else? It was pink and melted right into your tongue, right? And your mouth is watering just thinking about...
    As low as $4.59
  • Fresh Strawberry Salt Water Taffy Fresh Strawberry

    Fresh Strawberry

    As low as $4.59
    Want to know the recipe for our gourmet Fresh Strawberry salt water taffy? Sweet. Pink. Creamy. And absolutely dreamy. Taffy Shop's Fresh Strawberry salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA. Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 1/2 lb -...
    As low as $4.59
  • Red Velvet Batter Salt Water Taffy Red Velvet Batter

    Red Velvet Batter

    As low as $4.59
    Our Red Velvet gourmet taffy is tastier and far more charming than Gone With the Wind's Rhett Butler himself. Taffy Shop's Red Velvet Batter salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA. Approximate Pieces Per Bag: 1/2 lb - 30...
    As low as $4.59
  • Strawberry Cheesy Cake Salt Water Taffy Strawberry Cheesy Cake

    Strawberry Cheesy Cake

    As low as $4.59
    It stands to reason that if you're a lover of cheesecake and strawberries, you'll love our Strawberry Cheesy Cake gourmet taffy. You can't argue our logic. Taffy Shop's Strawberry Cheesy Cake salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the...
    As low as $4.59
  • Whipped Chocolate Salt Water Taffy Whipped Chocolate

    Whipped Chocolate

    As low as $4.59
    If you're looking here it's probably because you're a chocolate lover. Maybe it even goes as far as having an addiction to the stuff. Don't worry about it. Taffy Shop doesn't judge. We understand. And, may we add, our Whipped Chocolate salt water taffy...
    As low as $4.59