Taffy Shop's Gourmet Salt Water Taffy

Featured
Bestselling

Choose Options

Neapolitan

As low as $4.69

Look out! This gourmet taffy is a triple threat full of strawberry, chocolate, and vanilla flavor. Taffy Shop's Neapolitan salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA...

As low as $4.69

Choose Options
Choose Options

Fresh Strawberry

As low as $4.69

Want to know the recipe for our gourmet Fresh Strawberry salt water taffy? Sweet. Pink. Creamy. And absolutely dreamy. Taffy Shop's Fresh Strawberry salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with...

As low as $4.69

Choose Options
Choose Options

Bunny Poop Easter Mix

As low as $4.69

We found Little Bunny Foo Foo hopping through the Taffy Shop, leaving a trail behind- so we scooped it up and made the best mix ever: Bunny Poop. Happy Easter ya'll!Disclaimer: Don't worry, we tried...

As low as $4.69

Choose Options
Choose Options

Cherry Cherry

As low as $4.69

Remember your neighbors' giant cherry tree? You had to climb the ladder to find the sweetest, juiciest fruit at the top? Well, there's no need to put your life in your own hands anymore. Just order...

As low as $4.69

Choose Options
Choose Options

Red Licorice

As low as $4.69

Our gourmet red licorice taffy has that delicious, old-timey taste without the hassle of having to take your buggy to the general store. Taffy Shop's Red Licorice salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh...

As low as $4.69

Choose Options
Choose Options

Cran-Raspberry

As low as $4.69

We've tried to mix a lot of flavors together at the Taffy Shop and some are more successful than others. Case in point: our Cran-Raspberry salt water taffy. It's sweet and fruity and just a little...

As low as $4.69

Choose Options
Choose Options

Crazy Cotton Candy

As low as $4.69

Remember that time your family went to the circus and your parents bought you your very own cotton candy that you didn't have to share with anyone else? It was pink and melted right into your tongue,...

As low as $4.69

Choose Options
Choose Options

Red Velvet Batter

As low as $4.69

Our Red Velvet gourmet taffy is tastier and far more charming than Gone With the Wind's Rhett Butler himself. Taffy Shop's Red Velvet Batter salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in...

As low as $4.69

Choose Options
Choose Options

Unicorn Poop Taffy

As low as $4.69

What do Unicorns eat? Magical forest mushrooms. How else are they gonna fly? Once airborne, the Unicorns drop poop from far above the forest floor. The location of the Unicorn Poop Forest is known...

As low as $4.69

Choose Options
Choose Options

St. Patrick's Day Mix

As low as $4.69

Keep the pinches away with our newest green mix! Our St. Patrick's Day mix includes some tasty flavors including Sweet Spearmint, Juicy Pear, Granny Apple, Wild Watermelon, Key Lime Pie and Pineapple...

As low as $4.69

Choose Options
Choose Options

Spring Mix

As low as $4.69

Just in time for spring, this assortment includes some of our favorite fruity flavors. Enjoy Tangy Tangerine, Fresh Apricot, Huckleberry, Juicy Pear, Rad Raspberry, and Cran Raspberry. Taffy...

As low as $4.69

Choose Options
Choose Options

Strawberry Cheesy Cake

As low as $4.69

It stands to reason that if you're a lover of cheesecake and strawberries, you'll love our Strawberry Cheesy Cake gourmet taffy. You can't argue our logic. Taffy Shop's Strawberry Cheesy Cake salt...

As low as $4.69

Choose Options

Choose Options

Create Your Own 5 LB Mix

As low as $32.99

Can't decide which taffy to buy? We dont blame you! That's why we offer the Taffy Shop "Create Your Own Assortment" options. Don't settle for just one flavor, you've got five full pounds of variety...

As low as $32.99

Choose Options
Choose Options

Create Your Own 2 LB Mix

As low as $17.29

Can't decide which taffy to buy? We don't blame you! That's why we offer the Taffy Shop "Create Your Own Mix" option. Don't settle for just one flavor, you've got two full pounds of variety. Taffy...

As low as $17.29

Choose Options
Choose Options

Taffy Shop's Favorites Mix

As low as $4.69

You know what they say: sweets for the sweet. Give someone sweet in your life this delicious assortment of gourmet salt water taffy. This mix includes 22 of our top selling flavors, including Rad...

As low as $4.69

Choose Options
Choose Options

Create Your Own 1 LB Mix

As low as $9.49

Can't decide which taffy to buy? We don't blame you! That's why we offer the Taffy Shop "Create Your Own Mix" option. Don't settle for just one flavor, you've got one full pound of variety. Taffy...

As low as $9.49

Choose Options
Choose Options

Create Your Own 1/2 LB Mix

As low as $5.69

Can't decide which taffy to buy? We don't blame you! That's why we offer the Taffy Shop "Create Your Own Assortment" option. Don't settle for just one flavor, you've got a half pound of variety and...

As low as $5.69

Choose Options
Choose Options

Very Vanilla

As low as $4.69

We have one word that comes to mind when describing our gourmet vanilla taffy: CLASSIC! Taffy Shop's Very Vanilla salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA. Approximate Pieces...

As low as $4.69

Choose Options
Choose Options

Sweet Peppermint

As low as $4.69

Our gourmet Sweet Peppermint taffy tastes better than Christmas morning. Don't believe us? You might just be put on Santa's naughty list. Taffy Shop's Sweet Peppermint salt water taffy is guaranteed...

As low as $4.69

Choose Options
Choose Options

Tropical Mix

As low as $4.69

We took some lime, some coconut, and a bunch of other tropical flavors to bring you this mix. Taffy Shop's Tropical Mix salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA. Approximate...

As low as $4.69

Choose Options
Choose Options

Banana Dream

As low as $4.69

If you have a pet monkey, our banana flavor will undoubtedly be his absolute favorite kind of gourmet taffy. And may we add that if you have a pet monkey, we think you're pretty awesome. Taffy Shop's...

As low as $4.69

Choose Options
Choose Options

Unicorn Poop Taffy

As low as $4.69

What do Unicorns eat? Magical forest mushrooms. How else are they gonna fly? Once airborne, the Unicorns drop poop from far above the forest floor. The location of the Unicorn Poop Forest is known...

As low as $4.69

Choose Options
Choose Options

Dessert Mix

As low as $4.69

Our Dessert Assortment is the perfect mix of our favorite dessert flavored taffy. Flavors include: Strawberry Cheesy Cake, Caramel Cheesy Cake, Granny's Apple Pie, Banana Dream Pie, Campfire...

As low as $4.69

Choose Options
Choose Options

Black Licorice

As low as $4.69

What's black and white and delicious all over? Our gourmet Black Licorice flavored taffy! Taffy Shop's Black Licorice salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA. Approximate...

As low as $4.69

Choose Options