Dessert Mix

(9 reviews) Write a Review
  • Dessert Mix Salt Water Taffy
  • Dessert Mix
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Guide
  • Dessert Mix Salt Water Taffy
  • Dessert Mix
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Guide


Our Dessert Assortment is the perfect mix of our favorite dessert flavored taffy. Flavors include: Strawberry Cheesy Cake, Caramel Cheesy Cake, Granny's Apple Pie, Banana Dream Pie, Red Velvet Batter, Key Lime Pie, Birthday Cake Cake, Lemon Meringue Pie, and Cookie Dough! Taffy Shop's salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Approximate Pieces Per Bag:

  • 1/2 lb - 30 pieces
  • 1 lb - 60 pieces
  • 2 lbs - 120 pieces
  • 5 lbs - 300 pieces

Please note: This mix is combined in large batches, so each bag might not contain all flavors. If you are looking for specific flavors in equal weights, choose your own combination with our "Create Your Own Mix" bags. 

View AllClose

9 Reviews

  • 4
    Yummy but didn't get all flavors

    Posted by MP on 29th Nov 2020

    These taste amazing but in my bag I didnt get any strawberry cheesy cake, caramel cheesy cake or birthday cake. I only got 1 banana (ok with that) and 2 cookie dough. I figured it would be an even mix. I would still buy again cause they taste great!

  • 5
    Dessert mix

    Posted by Angel on 1st Jul 2020

    Grannys apple pie is yummie

  • 5
    Dessert Mix

    Posted by Beva on 30th Sep 2019

    This mix is to die for. The Red Velvet, Lemon Meringue and Key Lime Pie are my favorites. But really they are all fantastic. Consistently soft and the best flavors of taffy I have ever had. Will order again and again!

  • 5
    Classic dessert flavors

    Posted by Rita on 10th Jan 2019

    I loved it! I thought it was a great way to try out all classic dessert flavors in one go. My favorite was Spiced Carrot Cake, but the others are just as good.

  • 5
    Carrot cake

    Posted by Jenna on 9th Apr 2018

    These are so good but carrot didn't come in my mix.

  • 5

    Posted by Jessica on 12th May 2016

    So far I've ordered several different flavors and/or specialty packs...all of them fabulous! I have been giving taffy as gifts and each time I'm told it's the best taffy around!

  • 5

    Posted by Krista on 24th Mar 2016

    I am a die hard salt water taffy lover and these are by far my favorite!! The apple pie is just amazing. So much flavor packed into one bite.

  • 5
    Excellent taffy

    Posted by Unknown on 25th Dec 2015

    Very satisfied with the taste and quality of the taffy. The different flavors are fantastic. Will certainly tell others. Enjoy the holidays.

  • 5
    Best Birthday Treat

    Posted by Emily Gardner on 26th Jan 2015

    I absolutely LOVE this product. I ordered it for my boyfriend for his birthday because his favorite candy is saltwater taffy. This company has fast and safe shipping, excellent customer service, really adorable packaging, and an amazing and delicious product.

    Plus, me being a health nut, I really appreciate that their ingredients are a lot more traditional and do not contain dangerous added sweeteners like aspartame or high fructose corn syrup. I feel a lot better having found a company that makes a good product that I can give to the person I love and them enjoy it thoroughly.

    Also, I mentioned after my order that it was for a birthday and they added in a complimentary birthday card for me. Plus they added in a free sample package!

    I couldn't have asked for more and I would most definitely recommend this company to anyone. They will have my repeat business for sure.

View AllClose