Peanut Butter & Jelly

(1 review) Write a Review
  • PB&J Salt Water Taffy
  • Peanut Butter & Jelly
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Guide
  • PB&J Salt Water Taffy
  • Peanut Butter & Jelly
  • Taffy Shop Flavor Guide
$4.59

Description

Take a step back to your childhood when you lived on Peanut Butter & Jelly sandwiches all summer long. Our PB & J taffy combines that delicious peanut butter flavor with a hint of grape jelly. Just like mom used to make! Taffy Shop's salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Please note: Our Peanut Butter and PB & J taffy is flavored with artificial flavoring. It is not derived in any way from any type of peanuts. Our taffy is completely peanut free. 

Approximate Pieces Per Bag:

  • 1/2 lb - 30 pieces
  • 1 lb - 60 pieces
  • 2 lbs - 120 pieces
  • 5 lbs - 300 pieces
View AllClose

1 Review

  • 5
    AMAZING

    Posted by Jessica on 17th Feb 2017

    I can't stop eating these! All the flavors from my order taste just like the real thing, and this peanut butter & jelly is no different. A unique and tasty taffy! Great flavor, and not too sweet. If you even remotely enjoy peanuts or peanut butter, you've got to try this!

    I love the pb&j, and really everything from my order. They've got the perfect balance between a soft and firm chew, which only a fresh taffy can provide. Equally great for savorers (strong flavor from beginning to end) and chewers (incredible texture, doesn't get cemented to your teeth)! It's taking every shred of my willpower to not cancel my plans for the next few days and just chomp through every last Taffy Shop taffy.

View AllClose

Related Products

Chews the Right
Choose Options

Chews the Right

As low as $4.59
When faced with a tough decision, it's always better to chew on it before you decide. Simply pop in a piece of taffy and Chews! Funny Unique Gift For All Ages. This bag includes four of our...
As low as $4.59
Choose Options
Movie Popcorn Salt Water Taffy Movie Popcorn
Choose Options

Movie Popcorn

As low as $4.59
Want to know something even more delicious than sitting at a movie theater with a giant bucket of buttery popcorn? Buttered popcorn gourmet taffy. Taffy Shop's Movie Popcorn salt water taffy is...
As low as $4.59
Choose Options
Butter Rum Salt Water Taffy Butter Rum
Choose Options

Butter Rum

As low as $4.59
Yo ho, yo ho delicious Butter Rum flavored gourmet taffy for me! Well, actually it's for you, but you can see where we were going with this. Taffy Shop's Butter Rum salt water taffy is guaranteed...
As low as $4.59
Choose Options
Peanut Butter Salt Water Taffy Peanut Butter
Choose Options

Peanut Butter

As low as $4.59
Soon to be one of your favorite new flavors, our Peanut Butter flavored taffy uses a special blend of flavoring to create that peanut butter flavor while still being peanut-free. Taffy Shop's salt...
As low as $4.59
Choose Options
World's Best Mix
Choose Options

World's Best Mix

As low as $4.59
This is the assortment that you've been waiting for. We took 6 of our best-selling flavors and mixed them up to please your palette.  Flavors include: Crazy Cotton Candy, Rad Raspberry, Birthday...
As low as $4.59
Choose Options