Sugar Free Mix

(35 reviews) Write a Review
  • Sugar Free Salt Water Taffy Mix
  • Sugar Free Mix
  • Sugar Free Mix
  • Sugar Free Salt Water Taffy Mix
  • Sugar Free Mix
  • Sugar Free Mix


You can't be serious, sugar-free taffy that tastes this good? We wouldn't kid! It is sugar free and it is amazing! Flavors in this sugar free mix includes: Very Vanilla, Banana Dream, Fresh Orange, Black Licorice, Fresh Strawberry, Granny Apple, Cinnamon, Rad Raspberry, Huckleberry, and Whipped Chocolate. Taffy Shop's Sugar Free salt water taffy is guaranteed fresh. Made with love in the USA.

Approximate Pieces Per Bag:

  • 1/2 lb - 30 pieces
  • 1 lb - 60 pieces
  • 2 lbs - 120 pieces
  • 5 lbs - 300 pieces

Please note: This mix is combined in large batches, so each bag might not contain all flavors. If you are looking for specific flavors in equal weights, choose your own combination with our "Create Your Own Mix" bags. 

View AllClose

35 Reviews

  • 5
    Sugar Free Mix

    Posted by Diane on 12th Mar 2020

    Love this product! I cannot tolerate much sugar but I love salt water taffy! I found this and thought I would give it a try. So glad I did. Excellent!

  • 5
    You would not know this Taffy is Sugar Free

    Posted by Natalie Howell on 1st Aug 2019

    This is my first order from the Taffy Shop and I LOVE this sugar free Taffy:) The flavors are very tasty ! Will buy again and again:):)

  • 4

    Posted by Dan Tobin on 14th Aug 2018

    Good taffy. I wish the carb count was lower but still good

  • 5
    sugar-free: sweet result

    Posted by Dominik on 11th Oct 2017

    I didn't buy this for myself so I have no idea what it tastes like but it made the person I bought it for smile and that's priceless so I don't think you can go wrong with these.

  • 5
    Sugar-free taffy

    Posted by Nat Lucas on 20th Sep 2017

    This tragedy is by far the freshest & creamyest that I've had in a very long while. I'll be placing a bigger order next time.

  • 5
    Love this taffy

    Posted by beverly cavender on 17th Feb 2017

    I have ordered this taffy several times and I absolutely love it. ...I get sugar free because I'm diabetic. It has the most delightful flavors.

  • 5
    Oh My!!!

    Posted by Melissa Winters on 8th Dec 2016

    I have ordered these sugar free taffies and of course I had to try one or two. I could not believe that it was sugar free!!!! I would definitely order again!!

  • 5
    this taffy is delicious

    Posted by beverly cavender on 25th Oct 2016

    This is definitely gourmet taffy...does not taste like sugar free. I am absolutely hooked on this taffy...

  • 5
    Great Suger Free Candy

    Posted by BRAD HARDESTY on 6th Oct 2016

    These are relly great my had some and did not know they were suger free until I told her.

    No after bad after taste.

  • 5
    The best Sugar Free Taffy, ever.

    Posted by Sharon Berry on 18th Sep 2016

    This is my second order I have purchase of Sugar free Taffy and I will continue to order from the Taffy Shop. The sugar free taffy is so yummy and it does not taste icky like some sugar free products. It's so soft and it just melts in your mouth. I just love the sample they send every time with your order. Taffy Shop you are the BEST.
    Delivery is fast too.

  • 5
    The best Sugar free taffy

    Posted by Charlie on 12th Jun 2016

    I ordered the sugar free taffy and it was here so quick and then it was eaten so quick. It is the best and softest Taffy I have ever eaten. It don't stick to my dentures which is a plus in it's self. Thanks so much for the sample package too. I will definitely be a return customer. keep up the great making of the best Taffy ever.

  • 5
    Almost as good as the real thing

    Posted by Unknown on 9th May 2016

    As a type 2 diabetic I missed eating taffy. Not normally liking sugar free lollies I was apprehensive at buying this and having it shipped to Australia but knowing how good the traditional taffy was and reading reviews it was worth the effort.

    Having tried a lot of the different varieties so far I am very impressed with the product. Friends have also raided it not knowing that they were sugar free.

    Whilst it doesnt mean that you can eat too many at a time, at least I can now enjoy some when I want and have the variety so that it is not boring.

    They freighted well and traveled extremely well.

    I will be buying more, but wont need to for some time.

View AllClose